Easter in Tampa: Top 5 Traditional Easter Desserts to Ensure a Sweet Time

Easter screams gourmet food and spending good times with loved ones, and just like any other celebration, it is not complete without enjoying a sweet treat.

Luckily, Tampa is home to many top bakeries and restaurants that will satisfy your craving for a delicious traditional Easter dessert. So whether you are hunting for a fresh carrot cake or your sweet tooth craves a decadent coconut pie, you’ll find them in Tampa’s top-rated bakeries. Let’s dive in and ensure a sweet spring holiday.

Must Read: Best Easter Brunch Restaurants in Tampa Bay

Best Places to Find Traditional Easter Desserts in Tampa

Carrot Cake at Alessi Bakeries

Carrot cake is a classic Easter Dessert that never goes out of style. Tampa people can head to Alessi Bakeries for the best carrot cake in town. Customers cannot stop raving about how moist and delicious it is.

The carrot cake has spiced cake layers, cream cheese frosting, and chopped pecans sprinkles. Whether you want to treat yourself this festive season with a slice or a full delicious carrot cake for your whole family, Alessi Bakeries got you covered!

Hot Cross Buns from Sweet Buns Bakery

This England-made dessert is a staple during the Easter holiday, and it’s for a good reason. They are normally sweet and spicy, with raisins pardoned and a cross on top to represent the crucifixion of Christ.

Sweet Buns Bakery in Tampa has some of the most delicious hot cross buns. They make them fresh and come in packs of six. Try them out!

Key Lime Pie from Bake’n Babes

Lovers of tangy and refreshing desserts, here is something you’ll love this Easter - Bake’n Babes has some of the best-tasting Key Limes in Tampa.

They make theirs with fresh key lime juice and add a buttery graham cracker crust. It gives you the perfect combination of sweetness and tartness, so you can make it your go-to dessert for Easter family gatherings.

Coconut Cake from La Segunda Bakery and Cafe

Of course, the delicious coconut cake had to make it to the list of one of the best traditional Easter Desserts to ensure a sweet time. Thanks to its sweet and tropical flavor, this beloved dessert will brighten your Easter holiday.

You can get yours from La Segunda Bakery and Café in Tampa, and they make it so nicely. Theirs is usually moist with layers of vanilla cake, coconut cream frosting, and toasted coconut flakes – You’ll love it!

Lemon Cake from Wright’s Gourmet House

Lemon cakes are made with fresh lemon zest and juice and frosted with a tangy lemon glaze giving them a sweet and tangy taste. They are refreshing and just ideal to have after a heavy Easter meal. For the best lemon cake in Tampa, go to Wright’s Gourmet House. You’ll love what they serve to make your Easter sweeter!